Current Cases

Korean Publishers Association, et al. v. Google LLC, et al.

Status Current Case

Practice area Antitrust

Court U.S. District Court, Northern District of California

Case number 3:25-cv-04686

Overview

Cohen Milstein represents AdGuard Software Ltd. on behalf of a proposed class of Android app developers worldwide (excluding China) (“Plaintiffs”) in a putative cross-border antitrust and unfair competition class action against Google and its subsidiaries.

The plaintiffs, who distribute their apps or in-app products through the Google Play Store, claim that Google unlawfully monopolizes the Android app markets for distribution and Android in-app payment processing, enabling it to impose supracompetitive fees on app sales and in-app purchases while suppressing competition and foreclosing rivals.

Google allegedly maintains this monopoly through a combination of exclusionary agreements with smartphone manufacturers, restrictions on competing app stores, technical barriers that discourage app sideloading, contractual requirements tying distribution through Google Play to the use of Google Play Billing, and revenue-sharing agreements with major developers designed to deter competition.

Plaintiffs seek damages for the economic harm caused by Google’s unlawful exercise of monopoly power in the Android ecosystem and seek injunctive relief.

Case Background

More than 2.5 billion people worldwide use the Google Play Store every month. App developers create the apps and in-app products that consumers use and enjoy daily on phones using the Android mobile operating system (“OS”). Android has been available on mobile devices since 2008 and has been the most dominant mobile OS since 2011. Today, Android OS accounts for over 70% of the mobile OS market.

Plaintiffs claim that Google LLC and its subsidiaries have unlawfully monopolized the U.S. market, among others, for Android app distribution and in-app payment processing, enabling it to impose a supracompetitive 30% headline tariff on apps and in-app products sold on Google Play Store.

Google allegedly maintains this monopoly in multiple ways:

  1.  OEM Exclusion Agreements: Google obtained and maintains its monopoly status through agreements with original equipment manufacturers—i.e., smartphone makers—for use of its OS. The key agreements in this respect are Google’s Mobile Application Distribution Agreement, RSA 3.0, and Project Banyan and its successor agreements.
  2. Sideloading Barriers: Google deploys unnecessary and pretextual technical barriers to deter consumers from downloading app stores and apps directly from the web (often referred to as “sideloading”). These barriers include: (1) default settings to effectively block sideloading; (2) misleading official Android security warnings; and (3) other security mechanisms designed to deter consumers from using a competing app store or downloading apps from outside the Google Play Store.
  3. Tied Payment Processing: Google requires all Android app developers to enter into its adhesive suite of agreements, including the Google Play Developer Distribution Agreement, which, inter alia, specify Google’s ability to extract supracompetitive commission rates, prohibit the use of in-app payment processing services other than Google Play Billing, and tie the use of the Google Play Store to the use of Google Play Billing.
  4. Exclusive Developer Agreements: Google enters into anticompetitive agreements with large app developers, including revenue sharing agreements.

Plaintiffs further claim that, until recently, Google has forced developers to process payments for in-app purchases exclusively through Google’s billing system—at a cost of 30% on each transaction or 15% on the first $1 million of annual revenue that a developer generates through the Google Play Store.

By stifling competition, Google deprives consumers of alternative choices in the U.S. market, among others, for Android app distribution and in-app payment processing, and, as a result, it is able to command an anticompetitive commission of up to 30% on transactions made through the Google Play Store and Google Play Billing.

Even when litigation and regulatory pressure have forced Google to allow alternative billing methods in certain jurisdictions, including South Korea , India, the European Economic Area, and the United States, Google has imposed restrictions to foreclose competition.

But for Google’s exclusionary behavior, competition in the Android app distribution and in-app payment processing markets would have eroded Google’s monopoly power and constrained its ability to impose supracompetitive prices.