November 17, 2026
A Ninth Circuit panel appeared skeptical Monday over Meta’s bid to arbitrate certified class claims from roughly 9 million advertisers alleging Meta misled them about Facebook’s ad tools, with all three judges criticizing Meta for waiting until the metaphorical “eve of trial” to demand arbitration.
The judges’ comments came during a hearing before a three-judge panel on an appeal of U.S. District Judge James Donato’s December ruling that denied Meta Platforms Inc.’s motion to compel arbitration and stay proceedings in the high-stakes litigation, which was initially filed in August 2018.
Advertisers accuse the social media giant of raking in money by inflating the potential reach of advertisements to Facebook users. After multiple rounds of pleading, advertiser plaintiff DZ Reserve, which sells fitness products, and Cain Maxwell, who advertised firearm mounts, took over as lead plaintiffs and Judge Donato certified a class in March 2022, which Meta quickly appealed.
In March 2024, a previous, split Ninth Circuit panel affirmed the certification ruling in part, and on remand, Judge Donato set the trial for Oct. 14, 2025, but less than two months before — on Aug. 21, 2025 — Meta filed its arbitration motion. Judge Donato denied that motion, but allowed Meta to appeal while staying the trial date.
. . .
But throughout the hearing, all three judges on the panel questioned why Meta waited until less than two months before trial in the seven-year-old case to raise its arbitration demand.
. . .
Meanwhile, class counsel Matthew W.H. Wessler of Gupta Wessler LLP criticized Meta’s conduct as “gamesmanship,” and argued that Meta waited nearly seven years to file its motion to compel arbitration in August 2025, with trial set for October.
Wessler acknowledged that Meta mentioned its reservation of arbitration rights in a footnote in its opposition to the motion for class certification. But looking at the “totality of circumstances,” which he noted the appellate court must do, it’s clear that Meta waited too long, Wessler said.
Wessler noted that Meta never raised the arbitration argument initially in its affirmative defenses in its answers to the various complaints, even though Meta raised other class-wide defense arguments at the time, and the company never raised it as the parties argued over the class definition.
But crucially, Wessler said, Meta also never raised the arbitration argument in February 2025, after the Ninth Circuit remanded the case to proceed on a class-wide basis, as Judge Donato was considering summary judgment arguments.
Wessler argued that Meta even asked the court during a case management hearing to decide Meta’s summary judgment motion on a class-wide basis without mentioning that Meta believed 80% of the class was subject to the arbitration agreement. Meta additionally never sought to cite the arbitration agreement in the class notice, which makes the notices at issue distinguishable from the notices at issue in the Ninth Circuit’s 2023 decision in Hill v. Xerox Business Services LLC.
Wessler added that if a party is not engaged in “gamesmanship or sandbagging,” the defendant would anticipate that they would plan to seek to compel arbitration and tell opposing counsel, as well as the court early in litigation, so that the judge can effectively manage the case docket and potentially narrow discovery.
That never happened in this case, he argued, and when considered altogether, “that should be enough waiver.”
The class of advertisers were represented during the hearing by Matthew W.H. Wessler of Gupta Wessler LLP and Geoffrey Graber of Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll LLP.